Crime and Punishment Essay Question Some people believe that each type of crime should be met with specific punishment. Other people disagree and feel that various factors, such as an individual's situation or motivation for committing a crime, must always be considered when determining the penalty. What is your opinion? Discuss both views. Crime and Punishment Essay Answer It is one thing to determine if a crime has been committed based on evidence, but another thing to establish how and why the crime was committed. For this reason, in most democratic countries, the judicial system exists based on a jury and a judge. The jury is responsible for determining if the evidence clearly indicates that a particular crime was committed and the judge is responsible for passing an appropriate sentence based on the facts and circumstances of the case in question. Although some people think fixed sentences for each crime would be better, irrespective of the reason or ma